Bit-Depth of Adjustment Layers

Hello. I have a question about adjustment layers. Are they affected by
the bit-depth of the document? It is my guess that they are not since
the controls only offer 8-bit values to work with.
The goal is to reduce 16-bit layered files to 8-bit and save to disk
using a scaled-down image. Should corrections be needed later, then the
16-bit full size image is still available (in the camera RAW format)
and then the adjustment layers can be copied back from the scaled 8-bit
image. I am not concerned with any issues regarding resolution or
bit-depth of layer masks...
Does anyone see anyting wrong with this workflow?
Is there any documentation anywhere that states whether adjustment
layers are bit-depth dependent or not?
Thanks!
Ken

Ken


Re: Bit-Depth of Adjustment Layers

I tend to agree. What matters though, regarding the documentation, is
to provide a valid reason to my supervisors for suggesting a change in
their workflow that they have established. I'm pretty sure I'm right,
but it would help to back up my opinion with some technical data.
Ken


Ken


Re: Bit-Depth of Adjustment Layers

Although you are not concerned with that, for the sake of anyone else
the layer mask bit-depth appears to be the same as that of the image
itself. (They can take up twice as much file space in the 16-bit case
for the same number of pixels).
If you are not worried about the loss of quality of the layer masks, I
think this will work. I use a related method - I do ACR raw conversion
at 8-bit, not 16-bit, for use in Photoshop, for efficiency. (I ran
tests that showed no relevant difference for my images, as long as I
get a good histogram in ACR). If I need 16-bit working later, I can
reconvert at 16-bit and remake the image in the way you suggest.
(However, I keep all the pixels). Needless to say, I would also need to
redo any pixel-changes, such as cloning & patching! It is not something
I want, or expect, to do often.
Since I create my layer masks while working in 8-bit, I am not in the
position of throwing away their quality by converting from 16-bit to
8-bit, then wanting it back.
I haven't seen any documentation on this, but my brief tests tell me
that, when I copy adjustment layers between 8-bit and 16-bit images, I
get the same values in the adjustment dialogue boxes in both images.
What else matters?
--
Barry Pearson
http://www.barry.pearson.name/photography/


Barry Pearson


Content - Bit-Depth of Adjustment Layers
Found 2 post(s). Page 1 of 1
| 1 |










 
Ugl - Transport - Property In South Africa - Platzreife Golf - TRÄMINUTEN I UDDEVALLA AB
Photoshop questions